Excalibur Scroll Saw Review: Worth the Price Tag or Pass?

Are you tired of searching for the perfect scroll saw that can handle your woodworking projects? You are not alone.

Many woodworkers struggle to find a reliable tool that offers precision cuts without breaking the bank. The good news is that Excalibur scroll saws have earned their reputation as top performers in the woodworking community.

This review will help you discover the best Excalibur scroll saw models available on Amazon and guide you toward making the right choice for your workshop.

Key Takeaways

• Excalibur offers three main models – the EX-16 (16-inch), EX-21 (21-inch), and EX-30 (30-inch) – each designed for different workshop sizes and project requirements
• The tilting head feature sets these saws apart from competitors because the cutting head tilts instead of the table, keeping your workpiece level during angled cuts
• Minimal vibration means cleaner cuts and less fatigue during long work sessions, thanks to the counterbalanced drive system
• Variable speed control ranges from 400 to 1550 strokes per minute depending on the model, giving you complete control over your cutting speed
• These saws accept pinless blades only, which provides better control for detailed fretwork and intricate patterns compared to pinned blade systems
• Amazon offers competitive pricing on Excalibur models, though availability can vary, so checking for alternative quality brands like DeWalt and WEN is smart

What Makes Excalibur Scroll Saws Stand Out

Excalibur scroll saws have built a strong following among woodworkers for good reasons. The unique tilting head design represents the biggest difference between these machines and other brands.

While most scroll saws tilt the table to create angled cuts, Excalibur tilts the entire cutting head. This design keeps your workpiece flat and stable on the table.

The construction quality deserves attention too. These machines use heavy steel plates that reduce vibration to almost nothing. You will notice this difference when you start cutting. The smooth operation means you can work longer without hand fatigue. The precision stays consistent even at maximum speed.

Variable speed control gives you flexibility for different materials. Softer woods cut well at higher speeds. Harder materials need slower speeds for better control. The 1.3 amp constant torque motor delivers consistent power across all speed ranges.

General International Excalibur EX-21CRB Tilting Head Scroll Saw

The EX-21 model represents the most popular choice in the Excalibur lineup. This 21-inch throat capacity scroll saw handles large projects with ease. The cutting capacity reaches 2 inches thick, perfect for most woodworking applications.

The tilting head moves 38 degrees to the left and 45 degrees to the right. This range covers virtually all angled cutting needs. The foot switch controller comes included, leaving your hands free to guide the workpiece. This feature proves valuable for detailed work.

The table measures generous proportions, providing stable support for large pieces. Tool-free blade changes make switching between different blade sizes quick and simple. The dust port connects to standard shop vacuum systems for cleaner operation.

Understanding the Excalibur EX-16 Compact Model

The EX-16 brings Excalibur quality to smaller workshops. This 16-inch throat capacity saw fits on compact workbenches while maintaining the features that make Excalibur special. The table size measures 12 inches wide by 18.5 inches deep.

This model cuts up to 1.9 inches thick. That depth works fine for most scroll saw projects. The variable speed ranges from 400 to 1400 strokes per minute. Low vibration operation remains a key feature even in this smaller package.

The scaled-down size does create some limitations. Large projects will not fit comfortably. But if you work mainly on small to medium projects, this saw delivers excellent value. The price point sits lower than the EX-21 too.

Top 3 Alternatives for Excalibur Scroll Saw

DeWalt DW788 Variable Speed Scroll Saw

The DeWalt DW788 stands as a direct competitor to Excalibur models. This 20-inch scroll saw uses a different approach with a tilting table design. The double parallel arm system reduces vibration effectively.

Variable speed control offers precise adjustments. The tool-free blade changes take only seconds. The dust blower keeps your cutting line visible. A work light illuminates the cutting area.

Many woodworkers compare this saw directly to Excalibur models. The DeWalt costs more but includes features some users prefer. The choice between tilting head and tilting table comes down to personal preference.

WEN 3921 Variable Speed Scroll Saw

The WEN 3921 offers excellent value for beginners and hobbyists. This 16-inch scroll saw includes a work light and flexible dust port. The variable speed ranges from 400 to 1600 strokes per minute.

The cast iron base provides stability. The flexible LED work light bends to illuminate your cutting line from any angle. The dust port connects to standard shop vacuums.

This saw accepts both pinned and pinless blades. That flexibility helps beginners who want to experiment with different blade types. The price sits significantly lower than Excalibur or DeWalt options.

Bucktool Variable Speed Scroll Saw

Bucktool offers a 22-inch throat capacity at a mid-range price point. The 1.3 amp motor provides steady cutting power. Variable speed control adjusts to different materials and cutting requirements.

The large cast iron table stays flat and stable during operation. Tool-free blade changes speed up your workflow. The dust blower keeps the cutting line visible without stopping work.

User reviews highlight the smooth operation and good value for money. This option bridges the gap between budget models and premium brands.

The Importance of Variable Speed Control

Variable speed matters more than many beginners realize. Different materials need different cutting speeds for best results. Softwoods cut cleanly at higher speeds. Dense hardwoods require slower speeds to prevent burning and blade breakage.

The ability to adjust speed while cutting helps too. You can slow down for tight curves and speed up for straight sections. This control improves cut quality and extends blade life.

Excalibur models offer smooth speed transitions. The constant torque motor maintains power across the entire speed range. You will not notice power drops at lower speeds.

Tilting Head Design Benefits

The tilting head design creates real advantages for many projects. Your workpiece stays flat on the table during angled cuts. This stability makes it easier to control large pieces.

Gravity helps hold the workpiece against the table. You do not need to worry about pieces sliding during beveled cuts. The table surface remains your reference point for all measurements.

Some woodworkers prefer tilting table designs. The choice depends on your project types and personal working style. Both systems produce quality results when used properly.

Blade Selection and Compatibility

Excalibur scroll saws accept pinless blades only. This limitation actually benefits serious woodworkers. Pinless blades allow smaller pilot holes for inside cuts. The lack of pins means you can use smaller blade sizes for detailed fretwork.

Blade changes require loosening and tightening the blade clamps. The process takes practice at first. Once you develop the technique, changes happen quickly. Some users install aftermarket quick-release clamps for even faster changes.

Blade quality matters as much as saw quality. Cheap blades break easily and produce rough cuts. Investing in quality blades from brands like Pegas or Olson pays off in better results and less frustration.

Maintenance and Long-Term Durability

Excalibur scroll saws need minimal maintenance. Regular cleaning keeps sawdust from accumulating in moving parts. A quick vacuum after each session prevents buildup.

The motor requires no special maintenance. The sealed bearings last for years with normal use. Occasional lubrication of the blade clamps keeps them moving smoothly.

Build quality affects long-term reliability. The heavy steel construction resists wear better than lighter materials. Users report these saws lasting decades with proper care.

Workspace Requirements and Setup

Consider your workshop space before choosing a model. The EX-16 fits smaller benches comfortably. The EX-21 and larger models need more space. Allow room around the saw for handling large workpieces.

Mounting the saw to your workbench reduces vibration further. Even though these saws produce minimal vibration, solid mounting improves stability. Some users build dedicated scroll saw tables with storage for blades and accessories.

Good lighting makes detailed work easier. Position your saw where natural light or shop lights illuminate the cutting area. The work surface should sit at a comfortable height to reduce back strain.

Price Considerations and Value

Excalibur scroll saws cost more than basic models. The investment makes sense for serious woodworkers who value precision and reliability. The reduced vibration and smooth operation justify the higher price for many users.

Amazon pricing varies based on availability and current promotions. Watching for sales can save money. Consider the total cost including shipping when comparing prices across retailers.

Factor in blade costs too. Quality pinless blades cost more than basic pinned blades. The improved results make the expense worthwhile for detailed work.

Safety Features and Considerations

Modern scroll saws include important safety features. On/off switches should be easily accessible. Some models include safety keys that prevent unauthorized use. The blade guard protects fingers from the moving blade.

Proper technique matters as much as safety features. Keep your fingers away from the blade path. Use push sticks for small pieces. Wear safety glasses to protect your eyes from flying sawdust.

The low vibration of Excalibur saws contributes to safety. Stable operation gives you better control. Less vibration means less chance of the workpiece shifting unexpectedly.

User Experience and Learning Curve

Beginners find Excalibur scroll saws easy to learn. The smooth operation and minimal vibration make controlling cuts easier. Variable speed lets you start slow while building confidence.

The tilting head takes some getting used to if you learned on a tilting table saw. The different approach makes sense quickly once you try a few angled cuts. Most users adapt within a few projects.

Online resources help new users learn proper techniques. Video tutorials demonstrate blade installation, speed selection, and cutting methods. The scroll saw community shares patterns and tips freely.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Excalibur EX-16 and EX-21 scroll saws?

The main differences lie in throat capacity and cutting depth. The EX-16 offers a 16-inch throat and cuts up to 1.9 inches thick. The EX-21 provides a 21-inch throat and handles 2-inch thick material. The EX-21 also features a larger table and comes with a foot switch controller. Your workshop space and project size should guide your choice.

Can Excalibur scroll saws use pinned blades?

No, Excalibur scroll saws accept pinless blades only. This design choice gives you access to a wider range of blade sizes and allows smaller pilot holes for inside cuts. Pinless blades provide better control for detailed fretwork and intricate patterns. While this limits blade options compared to dual-compatible saws, most serious woodworkers prefer pinless blades anyway.

How does the tilting head design compare to tilting table scroll saws?

The tilting head design keeps your workpiece flat on the table during angled cuts. This stability makes handling large pieces easier and lets gravity help hold the work in place. Tilting table designs like the DeWalt DW788 work well too but require different techniques for securing angled cuts. Both systems produce quality results. Your choice depends on personal preference and the types of projects you tackle most often.

What maintenance does an Excalibur scroll saw need?

These saws require minimal maintenance. Clean sawdust from the machine after each use to prevent buildup in moving parts. The sealed bearings need no regular maintenance. Occasionally lubricate the blade clamps to keep them operating smoothly. Check blade tension before starting work. The heavy steel construction resists wear and should last for decades with this basic care routine.

Are Excalibur scroll saws worth the higher price compared to budget models?

For serious woodworkers, the answer is yes. The reduced vibration leads to cleaner cuts and less hand fatigue during long sessions. The solid construction means better precision and longer lifespan. The tilting head design provides advantages for many project types. However, beginners or occasional users might start with a budget model like the WEN 3921 to learn basic skills before investing in a premium saw. Consider your commitment level and project frequency when making this decision.